Pizza Stop

Reviews

• Tim B.

  star star star star star 8 June 2026

  My wife and I were taking a ride and she felt like eating pizza. We stumbled across this place and they had gluten free pizza available (perfect). The gentleman behind the counter was very curteous and told me to give him about 15 minutes for the gluten free pizza. My wife had 2 grandma slices. My wife and I agreed that this was the best pizza we have ever had. Very crispy crust, delicious sauce and just the right amount of cheese. The gluten free pizza was absolutely delicious! Although this is out of our way, we will definitely go back for more. The location is in a run down strip but it has a nice old school pizzeria feel. Even though this is the case, I still give 5 stars.

• Ally G.

  star star star star star_border 1 June 2026

  This is our local pizza place hands down. There are quite a few others in the area, but pizza stop is tried and true, the best pie for miles around.  
  
  The place looks and feels 50 years old, and the crew behind the counter are old-school Italians (they even speak it to each other). Their practiced hands make pies all day, while talking to customers and conducting business, as easily as breathing.
  
  There's something comforting in that. They've just been doing their thing for years, and it's a great thing, and people appreciate it and keep coming back.
  
  We only ever get their regular pie, with various toppings like mushroom, pepperoni etc. They have other options but we always just stick with the classic. The garlic knots aren't the best I've ever had, but pretty good and we get them on the regular. They're also true to their wait times. If they say 15 minutes, that pie will be coming out of the oven at the 14 minute mark.
  
  One caution- they're largely a cash only business, but they do take plastic, if you're willing to pay an extra fee. Make sure to stop at the ATM beforehand.

• Jennifer H.

  star star star star star 24 May 2026

  Hallelujah for Pizza Stop! We travelled to Ronkonkoma for a slice at one of our top faves (Little Vincent's), then relized this is close by with excellent reviews.  Decided to give it a whirl ans we were blown away!
  
  Place is small and no frills but the older Italian gentleman was wonderful and made us feel almost like family.  We liked the fact they had a nice variety of special pies ready for the taking  :) Sampled a plain slice and garlic knot slice and we couldn't stop raving about iit even during our drive home.  Sauce for the regular slice is smooth with traditional flavors, you can tell quality of the ingredients, complimented by the cheese topping. Then their crust was simply stellar - crisp thin vessel for all the yumminess in the bite. Garlic knot slice did not disappoint as well.
  
  Can't wait to come back to try their other pies, then if there is consistency we've considered adding Pizza Stop to our shortlist of top 10 best pizza!

• B D.

  star star star star star 23 May 2026

  If thin crust crispy pizza is your thing, then this should hit the spot. Also got the large antipasto salad. It was a good sized portion. It's a paper plates plastic cutlery kind of place and not much to look at from the outside. So don't get put off by that. Overall, the choices for singles slices of pizza was fairly limited to plain and pepperoni so that could be better. So five stars for the single slice of plain pizza but four stars for ambience Limited single slice selection, and the salad.

• Rob P.

  star star star star_border star_border 17 May 2026

  I don't love when a bunch of my reviews sound alike but quite often the pizza places in Suffolk county have so much in common. Pizza Stop is no exception, 3 stars is perfect. It's good but very middle of the road. Crispy crust but not much else to report.